Production tax credits (PTCs) encourage wind energy by paying producers a fixed amount per kilowatt hour (kWh) of electricity for the first 10 years of a wind turbine’s lifetime. The federal PTC was first enacted as part of the Energy Policy Act of 1992 at a rate of 1.5 cents per kWh. Since 1992, the credit has lapsed and been retroactively reinstated over a dozen times, often at varying rates; its level in 2020, before the Inflation Reduction Act, was 1.5 cents per kWh. Shrimali, Lynes, and Indvik (2015) use data on wind generation investments in the US between 1990 and 2011. They estimate a state fixed-effects model with a vector of social, economic and policy control variables. The coefficient on the PTC dummy variable in their regression implies that the tax credit added 28.15 MW of wind capacity per state each year, equivalent to 1,407.5 MW across the US. Hahn, Hendren, Metcalfe, and Sprung-Keyser (2026) convert this estimate into an elasticity and use it to estimate the MVPF of a one-cent-per-kWh expansion of the PTC, implemented nationally in the US in 2020.
MVPF = 7.5
Hahn, Hendren, Metcalfe, and Sprung-Keyser (2026) imagine a policy that expands the PTC by one cent per kWh, and estimate every component for a wind turbine that produces one MWh a year over a 25-year lifetime (0.95 MWh a year after the first 10 years, since, following Kay and Ricks (2023), output falls by 5% once the PTC ends). The mechanical transfer is $10 a year, or $82.62 discounted over the 10 years in which the turbine is eligible for the PTC. Because the PTC covers only 10 of 25 years, they use a semi-elasticity with respect to the PTC for the upfront externalities and an elasticity with respect to the levelized cost of electricity (LCOE) for learning-by-doing.
Because the PTC is a large, non-marginal change in price, Hahn et al. (2026) convert the estimate of Shrimali, Lynes, and Indvik (2015) into an arc elasticity. Weighting each year by its capacity additions, the average annual addition is 6,328.33 MW, the average PTC 2.375 cents per kWh and the average LCOE 8.59 cents per kWh (2020 dollars). Since a one-cent change in the PTC is worth 0.4839 of a one-cent change in the LCOE in present value, the PTC lowered the cost of generation by 14.34%, while 1,407.5 MW is a 25.02% change in capacity additions: an elasticity of 1.746. With the 2020 LCOE of 3.299 cents, from Wiser et al. (2023), and PTC of 1.5 cents, this implies a 2020 semi-elasticity of 0.33, so a one-cent increase in the PTC raises wind installations by 33%.
The baseline PTC in 2020 is 1.5 cents per kWh, so the turbines induced by the expansion also receive the existing credit, a fiscal externality of $15 per induced MWh. Multiplying this by the semi-elasticity (0.33) and discounting over the first 10 years of the turbine’s life gives a fiscal externality of $45.11. The cost also includes the climate fiscal externality, the US government’s share of the avoided climate damages through higher future GDP and tax revenue, which Hahn et al. (2026) set at 1.92% of the global environmental benefit, including learning-by-doing effects; it lowers the cost by $12.54. The total government cost is $115.19 per turbine. Per $1 of program spending, the fiscal externality is $0.546 and the climate fiscal externality lowers the cost by $0.152, so the net cost is $1.394 ($115.19 / $82.62).
The willingness to pay (WTP) has four components: a mechanical transfer, environmental benefits, a rebound effect, and learning-by-doing effects. Hahn, Hendren, Metcalfe, and Sprung-Keyser (2026) value the transfer to inframarginal producers in full, so it equals the mechanical cost of $82.62 per turbine; the other components come only from the installations induced by the expansion. They do not include a change in producer profits: producers of wind power are assumed to be able to generate electricity from other sources as well, so if they optimize at the margin, the marginal kWh from wind earns no additional profit.
Hahn et al. (2026) estimate the emissions avoided by the marginal kWh of wind with AVERT, the Avoided Emissions and Generation Tool of EPA (2024), forecast the grid with the REPEAT Project of Jenkins and Mayfield (2023), and discount over the turbine’s 25 years. The monetized environmental benefit per kWh in the US in 2020 is 2.65 cents for local pollutants and 13.28 cents for global pollutants, and the grid forecast predicts that these values will decline over time. Converting each year’s benefits to a per-MWh level and multiplying by the semi-elasticity gives global and local environmental benefits of $501.18 and $66.62 per turbine. The added supply lowers the price of electricity and raises consumption, a rebound of roughly 20% of the environmental benefit that offsets $111.21. Lifecycle emissions from manufacturing, maintaining and decommissioning the turbines, which DOE (2023) puts at 11 grams per kWh, cost $16.57. Learning-by-doing, modeled with the learning rate of 0.194 from Way, Ives, Mealy, and Farmer (2022) and cumulative wind production of 742,689 MW in 2020 from Wiser et al. (2023), adds $270.71 of future environmental benefits and $75.98 of future price reductions. Summing across all components gives a WTP of $869.33 per turbine.
Per $1 of program spending, the WTP is the $1 transfer, $5.865 of global environmental benefits net of lifecycle emissions, $0.806 of local environmental benefits, a rebound that offsets $1.346, and learning-by-doing benefits of $3.277 (future emissions) and $0.920 (future prices), for a total of $10.522 ($869.33 / $82.62).
Combining these components, the MVPF is $10.522 / $1.394 = 7.547, the same ratio as $869.33 / $115.19 per turbine. Bootstrapping from the standard error of the causal estimate, Hahn, Hendren, Metcalfe, and Sprung-Keyser (2026) report a 95% confidence interval of [1.744, \infty].
In the paper’s own setting, using externality values for the US in 2011, the last year of its sample, the in-context MVPF is 8.040. With a social cost of carbon of $76 per ton in 2020 instead of $193, the MVPF falls to 4.479; with $337, it rises to 12.889. Across the three US estimates, the category average MVPF for wind production tax credits is 5.870 (95% CI [2.733, \infty]).
DOE (2023). “How Wind Can Help Us Breathe Easier.” US Department of Energy. https://www.energy.gov/cmei/systems/articles/how-wind-can-help-us-breathe-easier
EPA (2024). “Avoided Emissions and geneRation Tool (AVERT).” US Environmental Protection Agency. https://www.epa.gov/avert
Hahn, Robert W., Nathaniel Hendren, Robert D. Metcalfe, and Ben Sprung-Keyser (2026). “A Welfare Analysis of Policies Impacting Climate Change.” American Economic Review, 116(7): 2368–2421. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.20250166
Jenkins, Jesse D., and E. Mayfield (2023). “Rapid Energy Policy Evaluation and Analysis Toolkit.” Princeton University Zero Lab. https://repeatproject.org
Kay, Owen, and Michael Ricks (2023). “Time-Limited Subsidies: Optimal Taxation with Implications for Renewable Energy Subsidies.” SSRN Electronic Journal. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4392340
Shrimali, Gireesh, Melissa Lynes, and Joe Indvik (2015). “Wind Energy Deployment in the U.S.: An Empirical Analysis of the Role of Federal and State Policies.” Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 43: 796–806. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2014.11.080
Way, Rupert, Matthew C. Ives, Penny Mealy, and J. Doyne Farmer (2022). “Empirically Grounded Technology Forecasts and the Energy Transition.” Joule, 6(9): 2057–2082. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.joule.2022.08.009
Wiser, Ryan, Mark Bolinger, Ben Hoen, Dev Millstein, Joe Rand, Galen Barbose, Naïm Darghouth, Will Gorman, Seongeun Jeong, Eric O’Shaughnessy, and Ben Paulos (2023). “Land-Based Wind Market Report: 2023 Edition.” Department of Energy. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2172/1996790