A feed-in tariff (FIT) is the price that wind installers are paid for the electricity they generate. Since the installation market is competitive, the FIT closely tracks the levelized cost of electricity (LCOE) in each country, although it may also price in other benefits such as price stability. Bolkesjø, Eltvig, and Nygaard (2014) estimate fixed-effects panel models of cumulative onshore wind, solar and biomass capacity in France, Germany, Italy, Spain and the United Kingdom over 1990–2012, relating capacity to the share of an investor’s return that the FIT provides, together with other support schemes and controls. They find that FITs significantly raised onshore wind capacity, and they simulate the effect of raising each country’s FIT by one euro cent per kWh, holding other factors fixed. For Germany, using 2012 data, cumulative onshore wind capacity rises by 6,449 MW. Hahn, Hendren, Metcalfe, and Sprung-Keyser (2026) assume that US wind installers respond to changes in the cost of generation in the same way that European installers respond to changes in the FIT. They use the implied elasticity to estimate the MVPF of a one-cent-per-kWh expansion of the federal wind production tax credit (PTC) in the US in 2020, when the credit stood at 1.5 cents per kWh.
MVPF = 9.1
To obtain the elasticity, Hahn, Hendren, Metcalfe, and Sprung-Keyser (2026) divide the percent change in installed capacity by the percent change in the FIT. According to EWEA (2013), cumulative wind capacity in Germany in 2012, the year of the estimate, was 31,308 MW, so the simulated increase of 6,449 MW is a 20.60% change. The average FIT in Germany in 2012, as reported by OECD (2022), was $0.115 per kWh, or 0.096 euros at the average exchange rate over the sample period (1.20), so a one-euro-cent change is 10.42%. The elasticity is therefore 1.97.
Hahn et al. (2026) then construct the 2020 MVPF with the same approach and externality values as for their US PTC estimates: a policy that expands the PTC by one cent per kWh, evaluated for a wind turbine that produces one MWh a year over a 25-year lifetime, with a mechanical transfer of $82.62 over the 10 years of credit. Turbines induced by the expansion also receive the existing 1.5-cent PTC, which creates a fiscal externality, and the cost also includes the climate fiscal externality, the US government’s share of the avoided climate damages through higher future GDP and tax revenue, which Hahn et al. (2026) set at 1.92% of the global environmental benefit, including learning-by-doing effects.
Per $1 of program spending, the fiscal externality from the existing credit is $0.617 and the climate fiscal externality lowers the cost by $0.193, so the net cost is $1.424.
As in their US PTC estimates, Hahn, Hendren, Metcalfe, and Sprung-Keyser (2026) build the willingness to pay (WTP) from four components: the mechanical transfer to inframarginal producers, valued in full; environmental benefits from the emissions displaced by the induced turbines; a rebound effect, as the added supply lowers the price of electricity and raises consumption; and learning-by-doing effects through future emissions and future prices. They do not include a change in producer profits, since wind producers are assumed to optimize at the margin across generation sources.
Per $1 of program spending, the WTP is the $1 transfer, $6.629 of global environmental benefits net of lifecycle emissions, $0.911 of local environmental benefits, a rebound that offsets $1.521, and learning-by-doing benefits of $4.841 (future emissions) and $1.170 (future prices), for a total of $13.030.
Combining these components, the MVPF is $13.030 / $1.424 = 9.148. With a social cost of carbon of $76 per ton in 2020 instead of $193, the MVPF falls to 5.416; with $337, it rises to 16.385. Hahn, Hendren, Metcalfe, and Sprung-Keyser (2026) do not estimate in-context MVPFs for studies outside the US. Because the elasticity comes from outside the US and Hahn et al. (2026) must add the assumption that it carries over to US wind installers, this estimate is part of their extended sample, and it is not included in their category average MVPF for wind production tax credits (5.870).
Bolkesjø, Torjus Folsland, Petter Thørring Eltvig, and Erik Nygaard (2014). “An Econometric Analysis of Support Scheme Effects on Renewable Energy Investments in Europe.” Energy Procedia, 58: 2–8. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.egypro.2014.10.401
EWEA (2013). “Wind in Power: 2012 European Statistics.” https://windeurope.org/european/wind-in-power-2012/
Hahn, Robert W., Nathaniel Hendren, Robert D. Metcalfe, and Ben Sprung-Keyser (2026). “A Welfare Analysis of Policies Impacting Climate Change.” American Economic Review, 116(7): 2368–2421. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.20250166
OECD (2022). “Environmental Policy: Renewable Energy Feed-in Tariffs (Edition 2021).” OECD Environment Statistics (database). DOI: https://doi.org/10.1787/4b3ab1e9-en