The California Solar Initiative (CSI) was enacted in 2007 and is the largest state rebate program for solar in the US. It provides homeowners a lump-sum payment for residential solar in addition to the federal investment tax credit (ITC), a non-refundable tax credit for a share of the installation cost of residential and utility-scale solar that stood at 26% in 2020. Hughes and Podolefsky (2015) focus on the CSI’s rebates for home-owned solar. Using a panel of installations at the zip code level from 2007 to 2012, they exploit geographic variation in incentive levels to measure the relationship between rebates and adoption; in their preferred specification, the zip codes lie in a 20-mile corridor along the boundary between two utilities’ service territories, whose rebates changed at different times. They find that a $1 increase in the rebate per watt leads to a 101.09% increase in solar adoption. Hahn, Hendren, Metcalfe, and Sprung-Keyser (2026) use this estimate to calculate the MVPF of a marginal expansion of the subsidy for residential solar beyond the 26% ITC, implemented nationally in the US in 2020.
MVPF = 5.1
Hahn, Hendren, Metcalfe, and Sprung-Keyser (2026) report every component per $1 of program spending. In their 2020 baseline, a residential system costs $2.05 per watt net of the 26% ITC, based on the installed costs reported by NREL (2022), and each watt produces 1.44 kWh a year, following Barbose, Darghouth, O’Shaughnessy, and Forrester (2020) and Ramasamy et al. (2022), over a 25-year life. Because the elasticities they use are with respect to the installation price rather than the subsidy, they scale each induced effect by the pass-through rate, the share of the subsidy that reaches the price paid for the system. In the baseline, they use 81.1%, the average of the pass-through rates for home-owned systems estimated by Gillingham and Tsvetanov (2019) and Pless and van Benthem (2019).
To express the 101.09% semi-elasticity as a price elasticity, Hahn et al. (2026) divide it by the 77.8% pass-through that Pless and van Benthem (2019) estimate for home-owned solar, giving 129.93% for a $1 change in price, and multiply by the in-context cost per watt after the 30% federal ITC and the state rebate, $4.04 in 2012 dollars. The resulting elasticity, −5.25, drives the static environmental and fiscal externalities. Because their solution for learning-by-doing is undefined (infinite) when the product of the learning rate and the elasticity exceeds one, they use instead the elasticity of −1.13 from Pless and van Benthem (2019), from the same CSI program, for those effects.
The net cost has five components: the $1 mechanical transfer to inframarginal households that would have installed panels anyway, federal ITC spending on induced installations, state rebate spending (zero, since the baseline assumes no state rebates), lost tax revenue on utility profits, and the climate fiscal externality. The federal credit is $0.72 per watt, or $0.35 per dollar of the $2.05 net cost, which Hahn et al. (2026) multiply by the product of the elasticity and the pass-through rate: $1.496. Utilities lose profits as customers switch to rooftop solar. After a 20% rebound, a utility loses sales of about 1.15 kWh a year for each watt installed, and at government revenue of $0.006 per kWh of utility profit, discounted over 25 years and scaled in the same way, the lost tax revenue is $0.291. The climate fiscal externality, the US government’s share of the avoided climate damages through future tax revenue, is 1.92% of the global environmental benefit (including learning-by-doing, net of the rebound and lifecycle emissions); it lowers the cost by $0.157. Per $1 of program spending, the fiscal externalities from existing subsidies and taxes total $1.787, so the net cost is $2.630.
The willingness to pay (WTP) that Hahn, Hendren, Metcalfe, and Sprung-Keyser (2026) estimate has five components: the mechanical transfer, environmental benefits, a rebound effect, learning-by-doing effects, and lost utility profits. The $1 transfer to inframarginal consumers is split between solar installers and homeowners: with a pass-through rate of 81.1%, 18.9 cents of it go to installers and the rest to homeowners. The monetized environmental benefit of solar output in the US in 2020, using the marginal emission rates of AVERT, the Avoided Emissions and Generation Tool of EPA (2024), is $0.125 per kWh for global pollutants and $0.025 per kWh for local pollutants, and the grid, forecast with the REPEAT Project of Jenkins and Mayfield (2023), is allowed to change over the panels’ 25-year life. Hahn et al. (2026) discount the stream of benefits per watt over that life, divide by the cost per watt, and multiply by the product of the elasticity and the pass-through rate. Net of lifecycle emissions from manufacturing, maintaining and decommissioning the panels, which NREL (2013) puts at 40 grams of CO2e per kWh generated, this gives global environmental benefits of $4.299 and local environmental benefits of $0.631 per $1 of program spending. The rebound, 20% of the local and global benefits excluding lifecycle emissions, offsets $1.054.
Learning-by-doing, computed with the elasticity of −1.13, a learning rate of 0.319, from Way, Ives, Mealy, and Farmer (2022), and cumulative global production of solar panels of 713,918 MW in 2020, from IRENA (2023), adds $4.988 of future environmental benefits and $3.987 of future price reductions. Utilities lose 1.10 cents of profit per kWh of solar output in 2020; scaled down by the 20% rebound, discounted over the panels’ life and multiplied by the product of the elasticity and the pass-through rate, this lost profit lowers the WTP by $0.535. Summing these components, the WTP is $13.316 per $1 of program spending. In their baseline, Hahn et al. (2026) do not add the induced households’ savings on electricity bills to the WTP, since a household’s decision to install already reflects them.
Combining these components, the MVPF is $13.316 / $2.630 = 5.063.
In the paper’s own setting, using externality values for California in 2012, the last year of its sample, Hahn, Hendren, Metcalfe, and Sprung-Keyser (2026) estimate an in-context MVPF of 1.872. With a social cost of carbon of $76 per ton in 2020 instead of $193, the MVPF falls to 3.565; with $337, it rises to 7.956. Across the five estimates in their main sample, the category average MVPF for residential solar subsidies is 3.862; across the estimates for which they have standard errors, the average is 3.282, with a 95% confidence interval of [1.967, 33.888].
Barbose, Galen, Naïm Darghouth, Eric O’Shaughnessy, and Sydney Forrester (2020). “Distributed Solar 2020 Data Update [Slides].” Department of Energy. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2172/1735556
EPA (2024). “Avoided Emissions and geneRation Tool (AVERT).” US Environmental Protection Agency. https://www.epa.gov/avert
Gillingham, Kenneth, and Tsvetan Tsvetanov (2019). “Hurdles and Steps: Estimating Demand for Solar Photovoltaics.” Quantitative Economics, 10(1): 275–310. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3982/QE919
Hahn, Robert W., Nathaniel Hendren, Robert D. Metcalfe, and Ben Sprung-Keyser (2026). “A Welfare Analysis of Policies Impacting Climate Change.” American Economic Review, 116(7): 2368–2421. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.20250166
Hughes, Jonathan E., and Molly Podolefsky (2015). “Getting Green with Solar Subsidies: Evidence from the California Solar Initiative.” Journal of the Association of Environmental and Resource Economists, 2(2): 235–275. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/681131
IRENA (2023). “Renewable Power Generation Costs in 2022.” International Renewable Energy Agency. https://www.irena.org/Publications/2023/Aug/Renewable-Power-Generation-Costs-in-2022
Jenkins, Jesse D., and E. Mayfield (2023). “Rapid Energy Policy Evaluation and Analysis Toolkit.” Princeton University Zero Lab. https://repeatproject.org
NREL (2013). “Life Cycle Greenhouse Gas Emissions from Solar Photovoltaics.” US Department of Energy. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2172/1056745
NREL (2022). “Solar Installed System Cost Analysis.” US Department of Energy. https://www.nlr.gov/solar/market-research-analysis/solar-installed-system-cost
Pless, Jacquelyn, and Arthur A. van Benthem (2019). “Pass-Through as a Test for Market Power: An Application to Solar Subsidies.” American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 11(4): 367–401. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1257/app.20170611
Ramasamy, Vignesh, Jarett Zuboy, Eric O’Shaughnessy, David Feldman, Jal Desai, Michael Woodhouse, Paul Basore, and Robert Margolis (2022). “U.S. Solar Photovoltaic System and Energy Storage Cost Benchmarks, With Minimum Sustainable Price Analysis: Q1 2022.” Department of Energy. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2172/1891204
Way, Rupert, Matthew C. Ives, Penny Mealy, and J. Doyne Farmer (2022). “Empirically Grounded Technology Forecasts and the Energy Transition.” Joule, 6(9): 2057–2082. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.joule.2022.08.009